The Bohr Model — Question 5

Section 7-4 · Chemistry pages 1095–1096

Show solutionHide solution

Question 5

Compare hydrogen with a one-electron helium ion

For a one-electron ion use En=−13.60Z2/n2E_n=-13.60Z^2/n^2 eV and rn=a0n2/Zr_n=a_0n^2/Z. Compare H (Z = 1) and He+^+ (Z = 2) at the same n.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the ratios of binding energies and model radii, He+^+/H.

  2. How do wavelengths for the same pair of principal levels compare?

Question 5 - Solution

Compare hydrogen with a one-electron helium ion

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Binding magnitude scales as Z2Z^2, so the ratio is 4. Radius scales as 1/Z1/Z, so the ratio is 1/21/2. Stronger nuclear attraction binds the single electron more tightly and contracts the model orbit.

(b) Analysis

Transition energy scales by 4, so photon wavelength for He+^+ is one-quarter that for H, using λ=hc/ΔE\lambda=hc/\Delta E.

Check and interpretation

These relations neglect reduced-mass and relativistic corrections.