Show solutionHide solution
Question 10
Separate the identity of an element from the state of its electrons
A student argues that aqueous NaCl must show the same chemical behavior as sodium metal because both contain nuclei with Z = 11. In the ideal solution model, NaCl supplies and .
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Compare the electron counts and outer configurations of neutral Na and .
Explain why shared nuclear identity does not imply the same water reactivity or the same charge carriers in electrical conduction.
Question 10 - Solution
Separate the identity of an element from the state of its electrons
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Neutral Na has eleven electrons, ; has ten, [Ne]. Both nuclei are sodium nuclei, but their electronic states and chemical environments differ.
(b) Analysis
Sodium metal can donate outer electrons during reaction with water. Aqueous is already oxidized and does not behave as neutral metal merely because Z is unchanged. Metallic conduction involves mobile electrons; ideal aqueous NaCl conducts by motion of positive and negative ions. Elemental identity is not a complete specification of chemical state.
Check and interpretation
Changing charge or chemical environment does not change the proton number.