Show solutionHide solution
Question 8
Apply a filling rule while stating what it does not prove
The empirical mnemonic orders lower first, with lower n breaking ties. Apply it to 4s, 3d and 4p, where s has , p has 1 and d has 2.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Derive the mnemonic filling sequence.
Does this derivation establish a fixed orbital-energy order for every atom and ion?
Question 8 - Solution
Apply a filling rule while stating what it does not prove
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
For 4s, ; for 3d it is 5; for 4p it is 5. The tie puts 3d before 4p because 3 is smaller than 4. Thus the mnemonic sequence is .
(b) Analysis
No. Occupancy, nuclear charge and electron interactions alter relative energies. The mnemonic summarizes many neutral ground configurations but does not prove an immutable spectrum, nor the order of electron removal in transition-metal ions.
Check and interpretation
This exercise distinguishes an empirical organizing rule from a general energy theorem.