Show solutionHide solution
Question 6
Use observed exceptions to limit a filling mnemonic
The observed neutral-atom ground configurations are Cr (Z = 24): and Cu (Z = 29): . A rigid filling mnemonic would place two electrons in 4s first.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Write the two rigid-mnemonic predictions and compare their electron totals with observation.
Explain why the discrepancy is about total energy, and why a universal half-filled/full-filled slogan is inadequate.
Question 6 - Solution
Use observed exceptions to limit a filling mnemonic
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
The rigid predictions are Cr: and Cu: . Both predicted and observed forms have the correct totals, 24 and 29. The difference is the distribution of one electron.
(b) Analysis
Nearby 3d and 4s configurations have competing total energies, including electron interactions. The observed arrangements are lower in total energy. Half-filled or filled subshells can help describe these examples, but do not replace an energy analysis or predict every exception.
Check and interpretation
The Aufbau scheme is a useful organizing approximation, not an infallible fixed ladder.