Show solutionHide solution
Question 4
Compare isoelectronic anions without erasing their identity
Phosphorus has Z = 15 and sulfur has Z = 16. Consider isolated and as formal electron-counting species. Argon has eighteen electrons.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Determine both electron counts and closed-shell configurations.
Are the two ions the same element or necessarily the same size?
Question 4 - Solution
Compare isoelectronic anions without erasing their identity
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
For , ; for , . Both have the formal configuration .
(b) Analysis
No. The nuclei have different proton numbers, and equal electron count does not imply identical electron binding or size. The larger nuclear charge in sulfur generally contracts an isoelectronic distribution. This counting exercise does not assert that both free anions are stable isolated gas particles.
Check and interpretation
Ion charge is protons minus electrons, in elementary-charge units.