The History of the Periodic Table — Question 7

Section 7-10 · Chemistry pages 1219–1220

Show solutionHide solution

Question 7

Keep isotopes in one periodic-table position

Two atoms have Z = 10 but mass numbers 20 and 22. A proposed table assigns a separate element position to every distinct atomic mass.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the neutron count in each and explain their elemental relationship.

  2. Why does atomic-number classification avoid the proposed duplication?

Question 7 - Solution

Keep isotopes in one periodic-table position

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Neutrons are A−ZA-Z: 10 and 12. Both atoms are isotopes of the same element, neon, because both have ten protons.

(b) Analysis

Atomic-number ordering assigns one position to Z = 10 regardless of neutron count. Neutral isotopes also have the same electron count and broadly similar electronic chemistry, though isotope effects can produce measurable differences.

Check and interpretation

Mass number is an integer proton-plus-neutron count, not the sample's average relative atomic mass.