Show solutionHide solution
Question 1
Test a triad as an approximate pattern
Early triad classifications grouped chemically similar elements. Using supplied relative atomic masses Cl = 35.5, Br = 79.9 and I = 126.9, test the suggestion that the middle mass is the mean of the outer two.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Calculate the predicted middle value and discrepancy from Br.
Does a close match by itself establish a universal law for all elements?
Question 1 - Solution
Test a triad as an approximate pattern
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
The mean is . It exceeds 79.9 by 1.3, about . The pattern is approximate for these supplied values.
(b) Analysis
No. A small selected group can show a useful regularity without supporting a universal exact rule. One must test additional families, chemical similarity and counterexamples, and account for measurement uncertainty.
Check and interpretation
Relative atomic masses are dimensionless; the classification also relied on chemical behavior.