New Energy Sources — Question 9

Section 6-6 · Chemistry pages 1023–1024

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Estimate energy payback without confusing it with carbon payback

A hypothetical energy installation requires 12000 kWh-equivalent to manufacture and install. It delivers 4000 kWh-equivalent per year and requires 500 kWh-equivalent per year in operating energy. All numbers use the same explicitly chosen energy-accounting basis. Assume constant output and a 20-year life; neglect end-of-life energy.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find energy payback time and net lifetime energy after all stated inputs.

  2. Can these data alone determine carbon payback time?

Question 9 - Solution

Estimate energy payback without confusing it with carbon payback

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Annual net energy is 4000−500=35004000-500=3500 kWh-equivalent. Payback is 12000/3500=3.4312000/3500=3.43 years. Net lifetime energy is 20(3500)−12000=5800020(3500)-12000=58000 kWh-equivalent.

(b) Analysis

No. Carbon payback also needs emissions factors for manufacturing and operation and a defined counterfactual for displaced energy. Equal energy inputs can have different emissions, so energy payback is not automatically carbon payback.

Check and interpretation

Comparing primary energy with delivered electricity without a common accounting basis could produce a misleading payback.