Present Sources of Energy — Question 9

Section 6-5 · Chemistry pages 1003–1004

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

Contrast nuclear energy release with chemical heating value

In a hypothetical nuclear process, the total final rest mass is 1.00 mg smaller than the initial rest mass. Use E=Δmc2E=\Delta mc^2 and c = 3.00×1083.00\times10^8 m/s. A comparison chemical fuel releases 45.0 MJ/kg.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find energy released and the mass of chemical fuel with the same energy release.

  2. Why cannot ordinary chemical formation-enthalpy tables determine this nuclear energy release?

Question 9 - Solution

Contrast nuclear energy release with chemical heating value

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

1.001.00 mg =1.00×10−6=1.00\times10^{-6} kg. Thus E=10−6(3.00×108)2=9.00×1010E=10^{-6}(3.00\times10^8)^2=9.00\times10^{10} J, or 9.00×1049.00\times10^4 MJ. The equivalent chemical-fuel mass is 90000/45.0=200090000/45.0=2000 kg.

(b) Analysis

Ordinary chemical reactions rearrange electrons and chemical bonds while conserving nuclei. A nuclear process changes nuclear composition or nuclear states and requires nuclear mass/energy data. The same energy-conservation principle applies, but ordinary chemical tables describe different endpoints.

Check and interpretation

The 1.00 mg is the total rest-mass decrease, not the starting fuel mass; electrical conversion would involve additional losses.