Standard Enthalpies of Formation — Question 8

Section 6-4 · Chemistry pages 981–982

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

Diagnose a products-minus-reactants sign error

At one temperature, a hypothetical isomer pair has ΔHf∘(A)=−120\Delta H_f^\circ(A)=-120 kJ/mol and ΔHf∘(B)=−80\Delta H_f^\circ(B)=-80 kJ/mol. A student reports -40 kJ/mol for A→BA\to B by subtracting B from A.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the correct enthalpy and explain the physical sign.

  2. Find the reverse enthalpy and the net enthalpy of an A to B to A cycle.

Question 8 - Solution

Diagnose a products-minus-reactants sign error

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

ΔH∘=Hf∘(B)−Hf∘(A)=−80−(−120)=+40\Delta H^\circ=H_f^\circ(B)-H_f^\circ(A)=-80-(-120)=+40 kJ/mol. B has higher enthalpy, so changing A into B raises enthalpy.

(b) Analysis

The reverse is -40 kJ/mol. Adding forward and reverse gives zero for the same amount returning to its original state.

Check and interpretation

Formation enthalpies share a reference, so their difference gives the state change for isomers of the same formula.