Effusion and Diffusion — Question 10

Section 5-7 · Chemistry pages 865–866

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Propagate a bounded rate ratio into molar-mass bounds

An unknown gas has rate ratio r relative to a 32.0 g/mol reference, with r in [1.95,2.05]. All Graham-law conditions are matched. Treat the reference mass as exact here.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Bound the unknown molar mass.

  2. Is 10.0 g/mol compatible?

Question 10 - Solution

Propagate a bounded rate ratio into molar-mass bounds

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

MX=32.0/r2M_X=32.0/r^2 decreases as r increases. Bounds are [32.0/2.052,32.0/1.952]=[7.61,8.42][32.0/2.05^2,32.0/1.95^2]=[7.61,8.42] g/mol approximately.

(b) Analysis

No. Even the largest allowed mass is below 10.0 g/mol. The direction of the inverse-square relation determines which rate endpoint gives each mass endpoint.

Check and interpretation

Uncertainty in a rate ratio propagates nonlinearly into inferred mass.