Show solutionHide solution
Question 4
Use two observations to identify a carbonyl isomer
Two pure compounds X and Y have formula C3H6O and are known to be either propanal or propanone. Both show a carbonyl signal in a stipulated spectrum. A selective mild oxidation test converts X into a three-carbon carboxylic acid but leaves Y unchanged. Assume the test behaves ideally for these two candidates.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Identify X and Y and give the oxidation product of X.
Explain why the carbonyl signal alone was insufficient and why the test result is conditional on the candidate set.
Question 4 - Solution
Use two observations to identify a carbonyl isomer
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
X is propanal, CH3CH2CHO, which oxidizes to propanoic acid, CH3CH2COOH. Y is propanone, CH3COCH3, which does not undergo the stipulated mild aldehyde-to-acid oxidation.
(b) Analysis
Both candidates contain C=O, so a generic carbonyl observation does not distinguish them. The selective test separates the two known possibilities. Without the candidate restriction, other carbonyl compounds or reactive groups could require additional evidence; one test is not a universal structure proof.
Check and interpretation
The aldehyde has a hydrogen attached to its carbonyl carbon; the ketone does not.