Show solutionHide solution
Question 7
Account for a changing mass denominator during decarburization
A 1000 kg melt contains only iron and 4.00 mass percent carbon. Carbon is removed without iron loss until the final melt contains 0.500 mass percent carbon. Ignore dissolved oxygen and all other elements.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Find the carbon mass removed and final melt mass.
Explain why subtracting 0.500 percent of the initial melt mass from the initial carbon inventory is not exact.
Question 7 - Solution
Account for a changing mass denominator during decarburization
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Initially there are 40.0 kg C and 960 kg Fe. If x kg carbon is removed, . Thus , so kg and final mass is 964.82412 kg. Remaining carbon is 4.82412 kg.
(b) Analysis
The final mass-percent denominator is the reduced final melt mass, not the original 1000 kg. Subtracting 5 kg from 40 kg would give 35 kg removed, but leaves 5 kg C in 965 kg melt, or 0.51813 percent, above the target. The correct balance preserves the iron inventory.
Check and interpretation
Final carbon mass divided by final total mass reproduces the target exactly.