The Crystal Field Model — Question 4

Section 21-6 · Chemistry pages 3553–3554

Show solutionHide solution

Question 4

Find a crossover temperature in a d6 model

For an octahedral d6 ion, assume ELS−EHS=−2Δo+2PE_{LS}-E_{HS}=-2\Delta_o+2P, with temperature-independent Δo=220\Delta_o=220 and P = 200 kJ/mol. The entropy difference is SLS−SHS=−100S_{LS}-S_{HS}=-100 J mol−1^{-1} K−1^{-1}. Treat these as a hypothetical two-state thermodynamic model.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the temperature at which the two states have equal Gibbs energy.

  2. Determine the favored state at 300 and 500 K and explain how entropy can reverse an energy-only preference.

Question 4 - Solution

Find a crossover temperature in a d6 model

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The energy difference is −440+400=−40-440+400=-40 kJ/mol. Therefore ΔGLS−HS=−40+0.100T\Delta G_{LS-HS}=-40+0.100T kJ/mol, which is zero at 400 K.

(b) Analysis

At 300 K the difference is -10 kJ/mol, favoring low spin. At 500 K it is +10 kJ/mol, favoring high spin. The high-spin state has larger supplied entropy, so its entropic advantage grows with temperature. Real crossover behavior may require temperature-dependent parameters and interactions.

Check and interpretation

The sign convention is low spin minus high spin throughout.