Show solutionHide solution
Question 10
Keep complex stability separate from exchange speed
Two hypothetical complexes A and B have formation constants and under the same concentration convention. Their first-order ligand-exchange constants are 10 s and s, respectively, under a specified substitution experiment.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Compare thermodynamic formation tendency and calculate each exchange half-life.
Explain how A can be more stable by the formation criterion but more labile in the substitution experiment.
Question 10 - Solution
Keep complex stability separate from exchange speed
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
A has the larger formation constant. Its exchange half-life is s; B has s, about 19.3 h.
(b) Analysis
Formation constants compare equilibrium free energies for defined reactions. Exchange rates depend on activation barriers for a pathway. A favorable complex can exchange ligands rapidly, while a less strongly favored complex can persist because replacement is slow. Stable/unstable and inert/labile should not be used as synonyms.
Check and interpretation
The constants refer to specified formation and substitution processes; a rate is not an equilibrium constant.