The Transition Metals: A Survey — Question 4

Section 21-1 · Chemistry pages 3453–3454

Show solutionHide solution

Question 4

Assess oxidation states using a complete energy cycle

For a hypothetical metal, producing M(III) rather than M(II) costs an additional 1800 kJ/mol in ionization. In environment A, extra product stabilization is -2200 kJ/mol; in environment B it is -1500 kJ/mol. All other enthalpy terms cancel.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Calculate the M(II)-to-M(III) enthalpy difference in each environment and state which state is enthalpically favored.

  2. Explain why variable oxidation states cannot be predicted from ionization energy alone, and what is missing for an equilibrium prediction.

Question 4 - Solution

Assess oxidation states using a complete energy cycle

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

In A, ΔH=1800−2200=−400\Delta H=1800-2200=-400 kJ/mol, favoring M(III) on this enthalpy comparison. In B, ΔH=1800−1500=+300\Delta H=1800-1500=+300 kJ/mol, favoring M(II).

(b) Analysis

Ligand bonding, lattice energy and solvation can offset an ionization cost differently in different compounds. Equilibrium depends on free energy, including entropy and actual activities or phases, so these enthalpy comparisons are not complete equilibrium constants.

Check and interpretation

The two environments use the same metal ionization cost but different stabilization.