The Group 7A Elements — Question 10

Section 20-7 · Chemistry pages 3425–3426

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Evaluate a complete reduction enthalpy model

For X2(g)+2e−→2X−(aq)X_2(g)+2e^-\to2X^-(aq), use the following hypothetical enthalpy terms per mole X2X_2: bond dissociation F2 +160, Cl2 +240; two electron attachments F -660, Cl -700; two ion hydrations F -1000, Cl -760, all kJ/mol.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Sum the three terms for fluorine and chlorine and compare the results.

  2. Explain why more favorable electron attachment alone would give an incomplete ranking and why these enthalpies are not themselves standard reduction potentials.

Question 10 - Solution

Evaluate a complete reduction enthalpy model

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

For fluorine the sum is 160−660−1000=−1500160-660-1000=-1500 kJ/mol; for chlorine it is 240−700−760=−1220240-700-760=-1220 kJ/mol. Fluorine reduction is more exothermic by 280 kJ/mol in the supplied cycle.

(b) Analysis

Electron attachment alone favors chlorine by 40 kJ, but bond dissociation and hydration reverse that isolated comparison. Standard potentials relate to Gibbs energy relative to an electrode convention, not merely these enthalpy sums; entropy and reference conventions are also needed.

Check and interpretation

A property of one intermediate step cannot replace the full thermochemical cycle.