The Group 7A Elements — Question 1

Section 20-7 · Chemistry pages 3407–3408

Show solutionHide solution

Question 1

Explain halogen phase differences without permanent dipoles

Use approximate boiling points F2=85F_2=85, Cl2=239Cl_2=239, Br2=332Br_2=332 and I2=457I_2=457 K. The melting points of bromine and iodine are 266 and 387 K. Compare the pure substances at 298 K and 1 atm; all molecules are homonuclear diatomics.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Identify the phases and explain the broad boiling-point trend.

  2. Explain why increasing permanent molecular dipole is not an acceptable explanation for the trend.

Question 1 - Solution

Explain halogen phase differences without permanent dipoles

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Fluorine and chlorine are gases because 298 K exceeds their normal boiling points. Bromine lies between its melting and boiling points and is liquid; iodine lies below its melting point and is solid. Increasing size and polarizability generally strengthen dispersion attractions down the group.

(b) Analysis

Homonuclear diatomics have no permanent bond dipole because the two atoms are identical. Dispersion arises from correlated fluctuating electron distributions and does not require a permanent dipole. Crystal packing also affects phase boundaries.

Check and interpretation

Boiling points alone would not distinguish liquid iodine from solid iodine; the melting datum is essential.