The Group 5A Elements — Question 5

Section 20-1 · Chemistry pages 3295–3296

Show solutionHide solution

Question 5

Compare base equilibria without equating them to bond strength

Two hypothetical Group 5A hydrides B and C obey B+H2O⇌BH++OH−B+H_2O\rightleftharpoons BH^++OH^-. Both initially have concentration 0.0100 mol/L. Use Kb(B)=1.0×10−5K_b(B)=1.0\times10^{-5}, Kb(C)=1.0×10−9K_b(C)=1.0\times10^{-9} and Kw=10−14K_w=10^{-14} at 25 degrees C; assume ideal dilute solutions.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Estimate hydroxide concentrations and pH using x≪C0x\ll C_0, and check this approximation.

  2. Explain why stronger basicity is not equivalent to a larger E-H bond dissociation enthalpy.

Question 5 - Solution

Compare base equilibria without equating them to bond strength

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

With x≃KbC0x\simeq\sqrt{K_bC_0}, B gives 3.16×10−43.16\times10^{-4} mol/L, pOH 3.50 and pH 10.50. C gives 3.16×10−63.16\times10^{-6} mol/L, pOH 5.50 and pH 8.50. The fractions reacted are 3.16 percent and 0.0316 percent; both satisfy a usual 5-percent estimate criterion, with B less accurate.

(b) Analysis

Basicity concerns proton acceptance and the free-energy balance for the complete aqueous reaction. E-H bond dissociation concerns a different process, usually homolytic cleavage in the gas phase. Solvation and the stability of both acid and base species also affect KbK_b.

Check and interpretation

The numerical bases are hypothetical; the results are approximate, and water autoionization is negligible at these concentrations.