An Introduction to the Periodic Table — Question 3

Section 2-7 · Chemistry pages 311–312

Show solutionHide solution

Question 3

Combine table position with material properties

Consider aluminum Al, silicon Si and sulfur S in period 3. Al is a metal, Si is conventionally classified as a metalloid, and S is a nonmetal. Hypothetical specimens show: P is malleable and conducts well; Q is brittle and semiconducting; R is brittle and a poor electrical conductor.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Match the specimens to the three elements using the supplied classifications.

  2. Why does brittleness alone not distinguish Q from R?

  3. Why should one use several properties rather than treating any single property as an infallible classification test?

Question 3 - Solution

Combine table position with material properties

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

P best matches Al, Q matches Si and R matches S under the stated data.

(b) Analysis

Both a metalloid specimen and a nonmetal specimen can be brittle. Their conduction behavior provides additional distinguishing evidence in this set.

(c) Conclusion

Categories summarize patterns, but individual properties can overlap and depend on conditions or structure. Combining composition, table position and several measured properties is more reliable than a one-property shortcut.

Check and interpretation

Metalloid is a useful conventional category, not an extra elemental particle type.