Molecules and Ions — Question 10

Section 2-6 · Chemistry pages 305–306

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Read a molecular model without treating the drawing literally

A ball-and-stick sketch of a water molecule labels one O sphere and two H spheres. Sticks indicate connections. A space-filling model of the same molecule uses overlapping spheres to represent approximate occupied regions. Neither is drawn here with a numerical scale.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Which atom-count and connectivity information can be read from the labeled ball-and-stick sketch?

  2. Why should the sticks not be interpreted as rigid rods of material joining hard balls?

  3. What can the space-filling model emphasize that a ball-and-stick model may obscure, and what information can either picture hide?

Question 10 - Solution

Read a molecular model without treating the drawing literally

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The sketch represents two H atoms connected to one O atom, consistent with H2OH_2O. Labels identify the elements without relying on color.

(b) Analysis

Spheres and sticks are visual conventions for atoms and bonds. Actual electron distributions are not hard balls attached by macroscopic rods; the representation omits the detailed electronic structure.

(c) Conclusion

Space-filling models emphasize approximate molecular shape and relative occupied space, while overlaps can hide atoms or connectivity. Either drawing can conceal depth in a two-dimensional view. Without a scale, neither yields numerical bond lengths by measuring the page.

Check and interpretation

Multiple representations can describe the same molecule while highlighting different information.