Show solutionHide solution
Question 2
Ask what a common charge-to-mass ratio establishes
Cathode-ray experiments using several cathode metals give the same measured magnitude . A student concludes both that the carriers are common constituents of matter and that equal ratios logically prove equal individual masses.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Why does the repeated result support a common-carrier interpretation?
Construct two hypothetical charge/mass pairs with the same ratio but different masses.
What independent measurement helps distinguish charge from mass?
Question 2 - Solution
Ask what a common charge-to-mass ratio establishes
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Changing the cathode material while retaining the same particle response suggests the carriers are not unique to one metal. Consistent results across sources support a common constituent, while still depending on experimental controls.
(b) Analysis
Pairs and both give . Thus equality of ratios alone does not logically establish equality of either quantity.
(c) Conclusion
An independent charge measurement, such as the elementary charge inferred from drop experiments, combined with yields a mass. Independent information breaks the ratio ambiguity.
Check and interpretation
Supporting a physical interpretation is stronger than a bare ratio but should not be confused with a mathematical uniqueness proof.