Dalton’s Atomic Theory — Question 5

Section 2-3 · Chemistry pages 235–236

Show solutionHide solution

Question 5

Use gas-volume evidence to test a particle picture

At the same temperature and pressure, assume equal gas volumes contain equal numbers of molecules. Two volumes of hydrogen react with one volume of oxygen to make two volumes of water vapor. Use the molecular models H2H_2, O2O_2 and H2OH_2O.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Translate the volume ratio into the smallest whole-number molecular reaction.

  2. Check the number of H and O atoms on both sides.

  3. Explain why an assumption that every elemental gas particle is a single atom would cause difficulty with these ratios.

Question 5 - Solution

Use gas-volume evidence to test a particle picture

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The ratio gives 2H2+O2→2H2O\boxed{2H_2+O_2\longrightarrow2H_2O}. Two volumes need not mean two actual molecules; they represent the same proportional counts.

(b) Analysis

The reactants contain four H atoms and two O atoms. Two water molecules also contain four H and two O atoms. All atoms are conserved.

(c) Conclusion

If two monatomic H particles and one monatomic O particle had to form two identical water particles, each product would require half an O atom. The diatomic elemental model removes that difficulty without splitting atoms in an ordinary chemical reaction.

Check and interpretation

Equal-volume comparisons require matched temperature and pressure; the equal-molecule assumption is explicitly supplied.