Fundamental Chemical Laws — Question 10

Section 2-2 · Chemistry pages 225–226

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Design a measurement that separates two proposed compositions

A new binary compound is proposed to have B:A mass ratio either 3/23/2 or 5/35/3. A pure sample contains exactly 6.00 g A for this model exercise. The B measurement has an inclusive bound of ±0.10\pm0.10 g; assume no other uncertainty.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Predict the B mass under each proposal.

  2. Give the possible measured-value intervals under the two proposals. Do they overlap?

  3. If the measurement is 9.95±0.109.95\pm0.10 g B, which proposal is compatible, and what should be done if neither proposal fits?

Question 10 - Solution

Design a measurement that separates two proposed compositions

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The first predicts (3/2)(6.00)=9.00(3/2)(6.00)=9.00 g B; the second predicts (5/3)(6.00)=10.00(5/3)(6.00)=10.00 g B.

(b) Analysis

Measured centers could fall in [8.90,9.10][8.90,9.10] g or [9.90,10.10][9.90,10.10] g. These intervals are disjoint, so this precision can distinguish the two stated predictions.

(c) Conclusion

The reported interval [9.85,10.05][9.85,10.05] g contains 10.00 g but not 9.00 g, so only 5/35/3 is compatible. If neither fit, investigate purity, calibration, stated uncertainty and alternative composition models rather than forcing a preferred integer ratio.

Check and interpretation

Choose sample size and precision so competing predictions are separated by more than their uncertainty ranges.