Show solutionHide solution
Question 6
Read chemical composition from the slope of a graph
The plot gives idealized exact elemental masses for pure compounds P and Q. P includes points and g; Q includes and g. Both relations pass through the origin.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Find the B:A mass ratio represented by each slope.
At fixed A mass, what is the ratio of B masses in P and Q?
What would a nonzero vertical intercept suggest about a proposed fixed-composition relation?
Question 6 - Solution
Read chemical composition from the slope of a graph
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
For P, slope ; for Q it is 3. Thus P has B:A = 2:1 and Q has B:A = 3:1.
(b) Analysis
The ratio is . This is a small whole-number ratio even though neither is twice the other; it is consistent with multiple proportions.
(c) Conclusion
For an isolated binary compound, zero A must correspond to zero B as sample amount tends to zero. A nonzero intercept may indicate a tare offset, background B or an unsuitable model, rather than a valid fixed ratio.
Check and interpretation
Slope compares composition; moving along a given line changes only sample size.