The Early History of Chemistry — Question 7

Section 2-1 · Chemistry pages 199–200

Show solutionHide solution

Question 7

Assess a repair to a failing combustion explanation

A hypothetical model says heating a metal removes phlogiston. When the solid gains 1.20 g, its defender assigns the escaping phlogiston a mass of −1.20-1.20 g. A rival predicts that 1.20 g of gas enters the solid.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Explain how the negative-mass assignment fits the observed solid change algebraically.

  2. Why is fitting one result not enough to choose between the explanations?

  3. Give a quantitative gas measurement that distinguishes the stated accounts.

Question 7 - Solution

Assess a repair to a failing combustion explanation

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

If the final solid mass equals the initial mass minus the mass lost, subtracting −1.20-1.20 g produces a gain of 1.20 g. The assignment reproduces the arithmetic by construction.

(b) Analysis

A flexible adjustment can fit an observation without yielding independent predictive success. A good comparison asks each account to predict another measurable quantity before that quantity is measured.

(c) Conclusion

The gas-combination account predicts a 1.20 g decrease in participating gas mass. Test this with a closed apparatus and separately tracked solid and gas. The escaping-component account must specify its own gas prediction to be comparably testable.

Check and interpretation

A model repair gains credibility through independent tests, not just a new label for the original result.