Show solutionHide solution
Question 4
Recognize why air need not be one substance
In a hypothetical early gas study, a fixed amount of metal reacts with only part of a confined air sample. After cooling to the initial conditions, residual gas remains and no longer supports the same combustion test. Do not assume the experiment has measured the composition of modern atmospheric air.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
What does this suggest about treating air as one chemically uniform substance?
Give an alternative explanation that must be excluded before inferring distinct gas components.
Propose a follow-up comparison using the initial and residual gases.
Question 4 - Solution
Recognize why air need not be one substance
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
The different chemical behavior suggests that air can contain components with different reactivities, one of which is consumed preferentially. It motivates a mixture model rather than proving a detailed composition.
(b) Analysis
The metal might be exhausted or coated by an unreactive layer, or the apparatus conditions might have changed. A stopped reaction alone does not prove that a gas component has been completely removed.
(c) Conclusion
At matched conditions, expose fresh equal metal samples to equal amounts of initial and residual gas. Control surface condition and heating. Different repeatable reactivity would support a composition change in the gas.
Check and interpretation
A qualitative reaction test cannot by itself supply exact atmospheric percentages.