Show solutionHide solution
Question 9
Distinguish silica composition from long-range order
Two compositionally pure samples produce the schematic diffraction profiles shown: A has sharp peaks and B a broad diffuse feature. Both retain local Si-O coordination. Assume instrument broadening is small.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Identify which profile supports a crystalline sample and which supports an amorphous glass. Explain what aspect of structure the contrast probes.
Evaluate the claim that glass has no atomic order at any length scale, and state one limitation of identifying a material from this qualitative sketch alone.
Question 9 - Solution
Distinguish silica composition from long-range order
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
A supports long-range periodic order and hence a crystalline sample; B supports an amorphous sample lacking that long-range periodicity. Diffraction probes spatial correlations, so identical chemical composition need not produce identical patterns.
(b) Analysis
Glass can retain short-range order, such as local Si-O coordination, without a repeating crystal lattice. The sketch does not identify a particular silica polymorph or quantify impurities, domain sizes or crystalline fractions. Actual calibrated peak positions and intensities would be required.
Check and interpretation
The broad feature is not a numerical peak fit; local order and long-range periodicity are distinct.