The Group 4A Elements — Question 4

Section 19-6 · Chemistry pages 3273–3274

Show solutionHide solution

Question 4

Separate hydrolysis stoichiometry from reaction speed

Under the stated aqueous conditions, silicon tetrachloride hydrolyzes readily whereas carbon tetrachloride reacts very slowly. Represent the silicon product by dehydrated SiO2SiO_2 and the other product by HCl; actual aqueous silica may be hydrated.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Balance the net silicon reaction and calculate HCl amount from 0.0250 mol SiCl4SiCl_4 with excess water.

  2. Explain why equal tetrachloride formulas do not require equal hydrolysis rates, and why an equation alone cannot establish the mechanism.

Question 4 - Solution

Separate hydrolysis stoichiometry from reaction speed

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

SiCl4+2H2O→SiO2+4HClSiCl_4+2H_2O\to SiO_2+4HCl. Therefore 0.0250 mol reactant gives 0.100 mol HCl in this net model. In water the acid is ionized; HCl denotes acid equivalents.

(b) Analysis

Central-atom size, bond polarity and accessible reaction pathways affect activation barriers. Shared stoichiometric form does not fix these barriers. A balanced net equation conserves atoms but does not identify elementary steps or establish a particular orbital explanation.

Check and interpretation

The question supplies observed relative rates; stoichiometry does not predict them.