Show solutionHide solution
Question 5
Include hydration when comparing alkali-metal oxidation energetics
For hypothetical cycles , use atomization, ionization and hydration enthalpies. For L they are +160, +520 and -520 kJ/mol; for S they are +110, +500 and -400 kJ/mol. The electron reference state is identical.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Calculate each cycle enthalpy and compare them.
Explain why the larger gas-phase ionization energy does not force L to be the less favorable aqueous reductant, and identify the extra thermodynamic quantity needed for a rigorous potential comparison.
Question 5 - Solution
Include hydration when comparing alkali-metal oxidation energetics
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
L gives kJ/mol, while S gives kJ/mol. L has the smaller net enthalpic cost because hydration more than compensates for its other costs.
(b) Analysis
Aqueous oxidation includes stabilization of the ion by water, so isolated-atom ionization energy is insufficient. Electrode potentials depend on Gibbs energy under defined standard states; entropy contributions and the common reference must also be included.
Check and interpretation
The supplied data illustrate competing contributions; they are not measured standard potentials.