A Survey of the Representative Elements — Question 3

Section 19-1 · Chemistry pages 3171–3172

Show solutionHide solution

Question 3

Order sizes within an isoelectronic series

The ions Na+Na^+, Mg2+Mg^{2+} and Al3+Al^{3+} each have ten electrons. Their nuclear charges are +11e, +12e and +13e. Consider a simple isoelectronic attraction model.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Predict their radius order from largest to smallest.

  2. Explain why this comparison is more controlled than comparing unrelated ions with different electron shells.

Question 3 - Solution

Order sizes within an isoelectronic series

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Increasing nuclear charge pulls the same ten-electron population more strongly inward. The expected order is Na+>Mg2+>Al3+Na^+>Mg^{2+}>Al^{3+}.

(b) Analysis

Electron count and occupied principal-shell pattern are held fixed, so nuclear attraction is the key changing variable. With different shell counts or coordination environments, additional effects complicate radius comparisons.

Check and interpretation

Ionic radii also depend on how they are defined and on coordination in solids.