Thermodynamic Stability of the Nucleus — Question 6

Section 18-5 · Chemistry pages 3117–3118

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

Compare electron-capture and positron energy thresholds

Use 1uc2=931.51\ \mathrm u\,c^2=931.5 MeV. For hypothetical neighboring neutral atoms, parent atomic mass exceeds daughter atomic mass by 0.000800 u. Use QEC≈(MP−MD)c2Q_{EC}\approx(M_P-M_D)c^2 and Qβ+≈(MP−MD)c2−2mec2Q_{\beta^+}\approx(M_P-M_D)c^2-2m_ec^2, with mec2=0.5110m_ec^2=0.5110 MeV. Neglect small electronic binding corrections and daughter excitation.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Calculate both Q values and decide which mode is energetically permitted.

  2. Explain why the positron formula subtracts two electron rest energies when neutral atomic masses are used.

Question 6 - Solution

Compare electron-capture and positron energy thresholds

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

QEC=0.000800(931.5)=0.7452Q_{EC}=0.000800(931.5)=0.7452 MeV. Qβ+=0.7452−1.0220=−0.2768Q_{\beta^+}=0.7452-1.0220=-0.2768 MeV. Capture is energetically possible; positron emission is not under these assumptions.

(b) Analysis

The atomic-mass difference includes one extra electron in the neutral parent compared with the neutral daughter. Positron emission also creates a positron. Consistent conversion between atomic and nuclear masses produces the two-electron-rest-energy subtraction.

Check and interpretation

Positive capture Q does not determine its half-life or a detailed emission spectrum.