Show solutionHide solution
Question 2
Use atomic masses without double-counting electrons
Use MeV. For a neutral mass-12 carbon atom, take atomic mass 12.000000 u, hydrogen-atom mass 1.007825 u and neutron mass 1.008665 u. Use , neglecting electronic binding-energy differences. Carbon has Z = 6.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Calculate the approximate nuclear binding energy.
Explain why replacing hydrogen-atom mass with bare proton mass while keeping the carbon atomic mass would be inconsistent.
Question 2 - Solution
Use atomic masses without double-counting electrons
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
u. Binding energy is 92.16261 MeV.
(b) Analysis
Six hydrogen atoms contain six electrons, matching the six electrons in neutral carbon, so electron rest masses cancel approximately. Bare protons contain none; mixing those masses would leave unbalanced electron rest masses and bias the result.
Check and interpretation
The approximation neglects small differences in electronic binding energy, not electron rest mass.