Corrosion — Question 4

Section 17-6 · Chemistry pages 2973–2974

Show solutionHide solution

Question 4

Compare scratched zinc and tin coatings on iron

Given reduction potentials Zn -0.76 V, Fe -0.44 V and Sn -0.14 V for their divalent-ion/metal couples, compare iron coated with zinc and with tin. Each coating has a small scratch exposing iron in a conductive wet environment. Assume active metals.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Predict which coating can protect exposed iron sacrificially and which can promote localized iron attack.

  2. Explain why an intact barrier coating can still protect even if it is more noble than iron.

Question 4 - Solution

Compare scratched zinc and tin coatings on iron

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Zinc is less noble and tends to oxidize, supplying electrons that help protect the exposed iron. Tin is more noble, so exposed iron can become the anode coupled to a relatively large tin cathode.

(b) Analysis

An intact coating can block water and oxygen from reaching iron, preventing the necessary electrochemical contact. A scratch changes the geometry and exposes the galvanic ordering.

Check and interpretation

Barrier protection and sacrificial protection are distinct mechanisms.