Cell Potential, Electrical Work, and Free Energy — Question 10

Section 17-3 · Chemistry pages 2925–2926

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Compare discharge output with minimum recharge input

A device undergoes a specified discharge with ΔG=−5.00\Delta G=-5.00 kJ at constant T,P but delivers only 4.00 kJ electrical work. Recharging restores exactly its original chemical state under the same conditions.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the reversible minimum recharge input and assess a claimed input of 3.50 kJ.

  2. Find the largest possible electrical round-trip efficiency with the stated discharge output.

Question 10 - Solution

Compare discharge output with minimum recharge input

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Reversal has ΔG=+5.00\Delta G=+5.00 kJ, so at least 5.00 kJ must be supplied. A 3.50 kJ recharge claim is incompatible with these endpoints unless some other energy source is consumed.

(b) Analysis

Even reversible recharge gives at most 4.00/5.00=0.8004.00/5.00=0.800, or 80.0 percent. Additional recharge losses lower this fraction.

Check and interpretation

The cycle must restore all relevant state variables before its energy accounting can be compared.