Free Energy and Work — Question 10

Section 16-9 · Chemistry pages 2865–2866

Show solutionHide solution

Question 10

Audit a claimed discharge and recharge cycle

Unless stated otherwise, use constant temperature and pressure, a closed system, and reversible pressure-volume exchange with the surroundings. Define useful work as work other than pressure-volume work; useful output is positive. A storage device goes from charged state C to discharged state D with ΔG=−10.0\Delta G=-10.0 kJ at 300 K. It delivers 8.00 kJ useful output. A proposed recharge method claims to restore exactly C from D using only 7.00 kJ useful input while exchanging heat with the same 300 K reservoir.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the minimum allowed recharge input and assess the claim.

  2. Find the largest possible round-trip useful-work recovery fraction if discharge remains at 8.00 kJ.

Question 10 - Solution

Audit a claimed discharge and recharge cycle

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The reverse state change has ΔG=+10.0\Delta G=+10.0 kJ. Recharging therefore requires at least 10.0 kJ input; the claimed 7.00 kJ is impossible under the stated constraints.

(b) Analysis

Even reversible recharging gives at most 8.00/10.0=0.8008.00/10.0=0.800, or 80.0 percent round-trip recovery. Any irreversible recharge requires more input and reduces that fraction.

Check and interpretation

Restoring every state variable matters; consuming an unreported chemical source would not constitute the specified cycle.