Free Energy and Work — Question 2

Section 16-9 · Chemistry pages 2849–2850

Show solutionHide solution

Question 2

Derive why useful work cannot exceed the Gibbs decrease

Unless stated otherwise, use constant temperature and pressure, a closed system, and reversible pressure-volume exchange with the surroundings. Define useful work as work other than pressure-volume work; useful output is positive. Use the chemistry convention that q and w are positive into the system. The first law at constant pressure gives ΔH=q+wnonPV\Delta H=q+w_{nonPV}. The entropy inequality for one reservoir at T gives ΔS≥q/T\Delta S\ge q/T.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Derive wnonPV≥ΔGw_{nonPV}\ge\Delta G and convert it to an output-work inequality.

  2. State the condition for equality and interpret an uphill process with positive ΔG\Delta G.

Question 2 - Solution

Derive why useful work cannot exceed the Gibbs decrease

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

From q≤TΔSq\le T\Delta S, wnonPV=ΔH−q≥ΔH−TΔS=ΔGw_{nonPV}=\Delta H-q\ge\Delta H-T\Delta S=\Delta G. Thus output Wout=−wnonPV≤−ΔGW_{out}=-w_{nonPV}\le-\Delta G.

(b) Analysis

Equality holds in the reversible limit. If ΔG>0\Delta G>0, useful work must be supplied: its minimum input is ΔG\Delta G, with real inputs generally larger.

Check and interpretation

The inequality reverses when multiplying the work-on-system convention by minus one.