Spontaneous Processes and Entropy — Question 4

Section 16-1 · Chemistry pages 2693–2694

Show solutionHide solution

Question 4

Assess a rare fluctuation without declaring it impossible

For N independent particles in equal halves of a box, every left/right assignment is equally likely. Consider the event that all particles occupy either one half or the other.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Derive its probability and evaluate it for N = 20.

  2. Explain why microscopic reversibility does not imply frequent macroscopic unmixing.

Question 4 - Solution

Assess a rare fluctuation without declaring it impossible

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

Two assignments qualify out of 2N2^N, so P=21−NP=2^{1-N}. For N = 20 this is 1.90735×10−61.90735\times10^{-6}.

(b) Analysis

Reversed trajectories are allowed by the microscopic model, but vastly fewer states represent complete concentration in one half than dispersed macrostates. For macroscopic N the probability is overwhelmingly small.

Check and interpretation

The probability includes either half; for one specified half it would be 2−N2^{-N}.