The Effect of Structure on Acid–Base Properties — Question 1

Section 14-9 · Chemistry pages 2447–2448

Show solutionHide solution

Question 1

Use a controlled across-period comparison

Consider the qualitative acidity trend for removal of one H from CH4CH_4, NH3NH_3, H2OH_2O and HF in a consistently defined comparison. Across C, N, O, F, electronegativity increases.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Predict the broad acidity order and explain conjugate-base stabilization.

  2. State why this does not imply all four acids ionize substantially in water.

Question 1 - Solution

Use a controlled across-period comparison

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

The broad increasing acidity order is CH4<NH3<H2O<HFCH_4<NH_3<H_2O<HF. A more electronegative atom in the same period better stabilizes negative charge after proton loss.

(b) Analysis

The first members are extremely weak acids in water. A relative ordering is not a claim of substantial ionization, and quantitative constants require a specified solvent and standard state.

Check and interpretation

A structural trend compares free-energy changes, not just the number of hydrogen atoms.