The Lewis Acid–Base Model — Question 8

Section 14-11 · Chemistry pages 2501–2502

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

Analyze competition between two donors

A metal binds either ligand X or Y in 1:1 complexes. Conditional concentration constants are KX=104K_X=10^4 M−1^{-1} and KY=106K_Y=10^6 M−1^{-1}. Free ligand concentrations are [X]=0.0100[X]=0.0100 M and [Y]=10−5[Y]=10^{-5} M. Other complexes are excluded.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find [MY]/[MX][MY]/[MX].

  2. Find the fractions of total metal present as free M, MX and MY.

Question 8 - Solution

Analyze competition between two donors

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

[MY]/[MX]=KY[Y]/(KX[X])=10/100=0.100[MY]/[MX]=K_Y[Y]/(K_X[X])=10/100=0.100. Despite its higher formation constant, Y gives less complex because its free concentration is much smaller.

(b) Analysis

The weights are 1:100:101:100:10, giving free M 1/111=0.901%1/111=0.901\%, MX 100/111=90.1%100/111=90.1\% and MY 10/111=9.01%10/111=9.01\%.

Check and interpretation

The supplied free concentrations already account for ligand availability; total ligand concentrations cannot automatically replace them.