Le Châtelier's Principle — Question 8

Section 13-7 · Chemistry pages 2281–2282

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

Check a phase constraint before applying a shift rule

Two vessels initially contain saturated ideal vapor of liquid A at the same temperature and pressure p*p^*. Vessel X also retains enough pure liquid A to supply additional vapor. In Y all liquid is removed without changing the initial vapor or gas volume. Both vapor volumes are then doubled isothermally and allowed to equilibrate.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Predict the final vapor pressure in each vessel.

  2. Explain why the same volume disturbance gives different final pressures.

Question 8 - Solution

Check a phase constraint before applying a shift rule

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

In X, immediate pressure falls to p*/2p^*/2, then some liquid evaporates until pressure returns to p*p^*. In Y, only vapor remains and its pressure stays p*/2p^*/2 under the ideal-gas model.

(b) Analysis

X has an available liquid phase to buffer vapor pressure. Y lacks the material reservoir required for that phase equilibrium; an undersaturated vapor cannot create extra vapor by evaporation of an absent phase.

Check and interpretation

The stipulated sufficient liquid in X prevents its exhaustion during expansion.