Show solutionHide solution
Question 7
Audit several claimed equilibrium measurements
Three ideal samples at the same temperature are claimed to be equilibrated. Their (A2, A) concentrations in M are X: (0.100, 0.200), Y: (0.400, 0.400), and Z: (0.200, 0.400). Use normalized concentration ratios with M and assume errors are too small to explain a factor of two.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Calculate the three inferred K values and identify the inconsistency.
Give two possible causes to investigate before altering the equilibrium law.
Question 7 - Solution
Audit several claimed equilibrium measurements
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
X gives 0.200 squared / 0.100 = 0.400; Y gives 0.400 squared / 0.400 = 0.400; Z gives 0.400 squared / 0.200 = 0.800. All three cannot represent the same ideal equilibrium constant.
(b) Analysis
Check that temperatures match and that Z was allowed to equilibrate. Also check concentration calibration, species identification and whether nonideal effects invalidate the ideal approximation.
Check and interpretation
Agreement of two samples suggests a useful diagnostic baseline, but does not by itself prove the third measurement alone is faulty.