A Model for Chemical Kinetics — Question 7

Section 12-7 · Chemistry pages 2119–2120

Show solutionHide solution

Question 7

Compare activation energy with the prefactor

Two first-order pathways obey kX=105e−40000/(RT)k_X=10^5e^{-40000/(RT)} and kY=107e−50000/(RT)k_Y=10^7e^{-50000/(RT)}, in s−1^{-1}. Use R = 8.314 J mol−1^{-1} K−1^{-1}.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find kY/kXk_Y/k_X at 300 K and identify the faster pathway.

  2. Find the positive temperature where the two constants are equal, assuming both laws remain valid.

Question 7 - Solution

Compare activation energy with the prefactor

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Reasoning and result

kY/kX=100e−10000/(8.314⋅300)=1.81k_Y/k_X=100e^{-10000/(8.314\cdot300)}=1.81. Y is faster at 300 K despite its larger activation energy.

(b) Analysis

Equality gives ln⁡100=10000/(RT)\ln100=10000/(RT), hence T = 261 K. The larger prefactor for Y compensates its larger barrier above this crossover in the supplied model.

Check and interpretation

Barrier height alone does not rank rates when prefactors differ.