Show solutionHide solution
Question 4
Assess a fit in concentration units
Two candidate models fit a dataset. For three independent validation times, observed minus predicted concentration residuals are F: (+0.001, -0.002, +0.001) M and S: (+0.008, +0.009, +0.010) M. Every concentration measurement has uncertainty about 0.002 M.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Compare the residual magnitudes and patterns.
Explain why a high straight-line correlation after transforming data is not enough to prefer S.
Question 4 - Solution
Assess a fit in concentration units
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
F residuals are at or below the stated uncertainty and change sign. S residuals are consistently positive and four to five times the uncertainty, suggesting systematic underprediction.
(b) Analysis
Transformations change error weighting and can make curved or noisy data look nearly linear over a short range. Check predictive residuals on the original measurement scale and the assumed error model, not only correlation coefficients.
Check and interpretation
The evidence favors F among these candidates but does not prove a unique molecular mechanism.