Show solutionHide solution
Question 2
Design a controlled light-scattering test
A colored liquid gives a visible side-scattered beam. A student concludes that its dissolved dye must be a colloid. Available controls are a clean solvent blank, a freshly prepared molecular dye solution of similar color, cleaned cells and a repeat measurement after removing dust by a procedure independently known to leave the target species unchanged.
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
Design a comparison that tests the colloid interpretation.
Explain what side scattering can establish and why color alone is insufficient.
Question 2 - Solution
Design a controlled light-scattering test
Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.
(a) Reasoning and result
Use the same illumination, cell geometry and detector settings for the unknown, blank and molecular dye control. Repeat with cleaned cells and dust removal. A signal above both controls that persists after dust removal supports dispersed scattering objects associated with the sample.
(b) Analysis
Color mainly reflects wavelength-dependent absorption and can occur in a molecular solution. Scattering supports heterogeneity on an optical scale but does not alone identify composition, particle size or thermodynamic stability; large debris can also scatter.
Check and interpretation
Controls are necessary because dust, scratches and bubbles can imitate a colloidal scattering signal.