Density — Question 9

Section 1-8 · Chemistry pages 163–164

Show solutionHide solution

Question 9

A dense metal can form a low-density sealed object

A sealed object made only of copper and a negligible-mass air cavity has mass 44.5 g and external volume 8.00cm38.00\ \mathrm{cm^3}. Copper density is 8.90gcm−38.90\ \mathrm{g\,cm^{-3}}. A proposed alternative is a cavity-free copper–aluminum mixture; aluminum density is 2.70gcm−32.70\ \mathrm{g\,cm^{-3}}. Assume metal volumes add in that alternative.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Find the object's bulk density and its cavity volume under the copper-shell model.

  2. For a cavity-free mixture, use ρbulk=fρCu+(1−f)ρAl\rho_{\mathrm{bulk}}=f\rho_{\mathrm{Cu}}+(1-f)\rho_{\mathrm{Al}} to find the copper volume fraction that would give the same bulk density.

  3. Can mass and external volume alone distinguish the two models? Suggest an observation that can discriminate.

Question 9 - Solution

A dense metal can form a low-density sealed object

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Infer a cavity under a stated model

ρbulk=44.5/8.00=5.5625→5.56g/cm3.\rho_{\mathrm{bulk}}=44.5/8.00=5.5625\longrightarrow5.56\ \mathrm{g/cm^3}.VCu=44.5/8.90=5.00cm3,Vcavity=8.00−5.00=3.00cm3.V_{\mathrm{Cu}}=44.5/8.90=5.00\ \mathrm{cm^3},\quad V_{\mathrm{cavity}}=8.00-5.00=\boxed{3.00\ \mathrm{cm^3}}.This inference depends on the copper-only assumption.

(b) Construct a competing model

f=5.5625−2.708.90−2.70=0.4616935…→0.462.f=\frac{5.5625-2.70}{8.90-2.70}=0.4616935\ldots\longrightarrow\boxed{0.462}.About 46.2% copper by volume, with the rest aluminum, reproduces the same density in the additive-volume model. This is not a mass fraction.

(c) Assess identifiability

No: both models reproduce the two bulk measurements. Imaging the interior could reveal a cavity, while elemental analysis could test for aluminum. Agreement with a density calculation does not uniquely establish internal structure or composition.

Check and interpretation

The bulk density lies between the two metal densities, so a mixture fraction between zero and one is possible.