Density — Question 6

Section 1-8 · Chemistry pages 157–158

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

Mixing volumes need not add

Liquid A has volume 40.0 mL and density 0.800gmL−10.800\ \mathrm{g\,mL^{-1}}; liquid B has volume 60.0 mL and density 1.00gmL−11.00\ \mathrm{g\,mL^{-1}}. They form a uniform mixture. No material is lost; after returning to the initial temperature the mixture volume is 96.0 mL.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Calculate the total mass and the mixture density to three significant figures.

  2. Calculate the density predicted by assuming additive volumes. State whether that prediction is too high or too low.

  3. Explain why averaging the two starting densities is not justified and why volume contraction does not violate mass conservation.

Question 6 - Solution

Mixing volumes need not add

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Add masses, then use measured volume

mA=(40.0)(0.800)=32.0g,mB=(60.0)(1.00)=60.0g.m_A=(40.0)(0.800)=32.0\ \mathrm g,\quad m_B=(60.0)(1.00)=60.0\ \mathrm g.m=92.0g,ρmix=92.096.0=0.958gmL−1.m=92.0\ \mathrm g,\qquad\rho_{\mathrm{mix}}=\frac{92.0}{96.0}=\boxed{0.958\ \mathrm{g\,mL^{-1}}}.Guard digits are retained before final rounding.

(b) Test the additive-volume model

ρadditive=92.040.0+60.0=0.920gmL−1.\rho_{\mathrm{additive}}=\frac{92.0}{40.0+60.0}=0.920\ \mathrm{g\,mL^{-1}}.This underestimates the density because the actual volume is smaller than 100.0 mL.

(c) Separate conservation from geometry

The simple average, (0.800+1.00)/2=0.900(0.800+1.00)/2=0.900, ignores the unequal amounts and the actual final volume. Mass is conserved; volume need not be. Rearrangement and interactions among particles can change the space occupied without removing matter.

Check and interpretation

The volume shrinks by 4.0 mL, while the total mass remains 92.0 g.