Uncertainty in Measurement — Question 6

Section 1-4 · Chemistry pages 77–78

Show solutionHide solution

Question 6

The same absolute bound has different relative importance

A delivery device has a constant absolute volume-error bound of ±0.02\pm0.02 mL over 1.00–25.00 mL. Consider deliveries of 2.00 and 20.00 mL. Define relative bound as u/Vu/V, and percentage bound as 100u/V100u/V. A procedure requires a percentage bound no greater than 0.50%.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Calculate the percentage bound for each delivery.

  2. Determine the smallest nominal volume that meets the requirement within the stated range.

  3. Explain why increasing the volume improves the relative bound without improving the absolute bound.

Question 6 - Solution

The same absolute bound has different relative importance

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Normalize by the measured scale

1000.022.00=1.0%,1000.0220.00=0.10%.100\frac{0.02}{2.00}=1.0\%,\qquad100\frac{0.02}{20.00}=0.10\%.The 2.00 mL delivery fails the stated requirement; the 20.00 mL delivery meets it.

(b) Solve the requirement

1000.02V≤0.50⇒V≥4.00mL.100\frac{0.02}{V}\leq0.50\quad\Longrightarrow\quad V\geq4.00\ \mathrm{mL}.The threshold is 4.00mL\boxed{4.00\ \mathrm{mL}} under the supplied constant-bound model and lies in the operating range.

(c) Interpret the ratio

The absolute possible deviation remains 0.02 mL. Dividing that fixed amount by a larger nominal volume makes it a smaller fraction of the delivery. This argument relies on the given constant-bound model; it should not be extended to other devices or beyond the stated range.

Check and interpretation

At 4.00 mL the percentage is exactly 0.50%, so the inclusive requirement is met.