Uncertainty in Measurement — Question 1

Section 1-4 · Chemistry pages 67–68

Show solutionHide solution

Question 1

Read an analog scale without inventing digits

The enlarged cylinder scale is marked every 0.2 mL. The bottom of the concave meniscus is halfway between the 12.6 and 12.8 mL marks. For this exercise, assign a reading bound of ±0.1\pm0.1 mL and assume other errors are negligible.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Report the volume with the assigned bound and give its interval.

  2. Explain why 12.7000 mL would misrepresent the information available.

  3. Does the stated bound automatically mean a 95% confidence interval? Explain.

Question 1 - Solution

Read an analog scale without inventing digits

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Read and bound the value

V=12.6+12.8−12.62=12.7mL.V=12.6+\frac{12.8-12.6}{2}=12.7\ \mathrm{mL}.V=(12.7±0.1)mL,V∈[12.6,12.8]mL.\boxed{V=(12.7\pm0.1)\ \mathrm{mL}},\qquad V\in[12.6,12.8]\ \mathrm{mL}.Read the bottom of the concave meniscus; the final reported decimal reflects the assigned reading bound.

(b) Avoid unsupported digits

The scale and stated bound do not support the extra decimal places in 12.7000 mL. Writing more digits does not improve the reading. The estimate between marks must remain consistent with the instrument and the specified uncertainty convention.

(c) Interpret the convention

No. Here the problem explicitly supplies a reading bound. A confidence statement requires a statistical model and a defined procedure; a plus/minus sign alone does not provide a probability. The assigned bound is an exercise assumption, not a universal rule for every cylinder.

Check and interpretation

The interval includes both neighboring marks. No finer detail is claimed than the reading method supports.