The Scientific Method — Question 8

Section 1-2 · Chemistry pages 41–42

Show solutionHide solution

Question 8

Rejecting a convenient outlier

Five nominally identical trials give reaction times of 61, 60, 62, 90 and 59 s. A student deletes 90 s solely because it spoils the expected pattern.

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

  1. Explain why the stated deletion rule is unsound.

  2. Calculate the mean with and without the 90 s result.

  3. Give a defensible response if the notebook records that stirring stopped during the 90 s trial.

Question 8 - Solution

Rejecting a convenient outlier

Diagram shown in the original SVG worksheet.

(a) Preserve evidence

Deleting a value because it disagrees with expectations biases the evidence. An unusual value should prompt an investigation of procedure and a transparent, justified treatment.

(b) Show the impact

t¯all=61+60+62+90+595=66.4s,\overline t_{\mathrm{all}}=\frac{61+60+62+90+59}{5}=66.4\ \mathrm s,t¯four=61+60+62+594=60.5s.\overline t_{\mathrm{four}}=\frac{61+60+62+59}{4}=60.5\ \mathrm s.The choice materially changes the summary.

(c) Document a protocol failure

Retain the original record, flag the trial as not meeting the stirring protocol, explain any exclusion, and repeat the intended trial. Report enough information to show the effect of the exclusion.

Check and interpretation

A documented procedural failure differs from a post hoc preference for a prettier result.